高等教育出版


 

 
 
篇名
論國際教育中愛國主義與世界主義的矛盾與出路   全文下載 更多文章
並列篇名
On the Contradictions Between Patriotism and Cosmopolitanism and Their Resolutions Within International Education
作者 黃文定
中文摘要
本文旨在運用教育詮釋學方法,爬梳國際教育中世界主義與愛國主義之間的兩種矛盾,分析Appiah「有根的世界主義」(或稱「世界主義的愛國主義」)觀點及其對兩種矛盾的調和,並闡釋國際教育面對矛盾的出路。Appiah世界主義觀點的兩項核心理念,是對人類尊嚴與自主性的普遍關懷與對差異的尊重。針對道德判斷觀點之普遍主義與社群主義的矛盾,Appiah承認普世價值的存在,但強調我們應接受不同地方對同一普世價值的不同詮釋與實踐方式的合理性,因此,教師應指導學生透過跨文化對話,理解不同在地脈絡的人對價值詮釋與實踐的多樣性。針對忠誠與認同對象之世界優先與國家優先的矛盾,Appiah指出我們應釐清「倫理」與「道德」兩種義務的區別,成為具多元忠誠與認同的世界公民,因此,教師應指導學生跳脫「國家-世界」二元對立,認識身分認同與義務之多樣性,自主地創造自我。
英文摘要
The purposes of this article were to adopt the method of educational hermeneutics to examine the two contradictions between cosmopolitanism and patriotism within international education, to analyze Appiah’s viewpoints of “rooted cosmopolitanism” (or “cosmopolitan patriotism”) and reconciliation of the two contradictions, and to elaborate the resolutions to the contradictions in international education. The two core ideas of Appiah’s cosmopolitan viewpoints were universal concern for human dignity and autonomy and respect for difference. In terms of the contradiction between universalism and communitarianism in moral judgments, Appiah acknowledged the existence of universal values, but emphasized that we should accept the legitimacy of different interpretations and practical approaches of the same universal value in different places. Hence, teachers should guide students to understand the diversity of interpretations and practices of values through intercultural conversation with people from different contexts. Regarding the contradiction of primary loyalty and identity between the state and the world, Appiah indicated that one should make a distinction of obligations between “ethics” and “morality” and can be a world citizen with multiple loyalties and identities. Therefore, teachers should educate students to go beyond the dichotomy of “nation-world” and understand the diversity of identities and obligations to create self autonomously.
起訖頁 041-078
關鍵詞 K. A. Appiah世界主義多元認同國際教育愛國主義K. A. Appiahcosmopolitanismmultiple identitiesinternational educationpatriotism
刊名 教育研究集刊
期數 201809 (64:3期)
出版單位 國立臺灣師範大學教育學系
DOI 10.3966/102887082018096403002  複製DOI
該期刊-上一篇 教育政治歧見之處理:由A. Gutmann民主教育觀點反思高中課綱微調爭議與出路
該期刊-下一篇 校長促進教師專業學習的槓桿:校長學習領導對教師課堂教學研究影響之中介模式分析
 
   
  國立臺灣師範大學教育學系教育研究集刊 Department of Education, National Taiwan Normal University
10610 臺北市大安區和平東路一段162號 / No.162, Sec. 1, Heping E. Rd., Da’an Dist., Taipei City 106, Taiwan (R.O.C.)
edber@deps.ntnu.edu.tw +886-2-77343892 Copyright 2012 © Department of Education, National Taiwan Normal University. All Rights Reserved.
  教育研究集刊